The Top 5 Beef Tallow Balms for Women — And the One I Told My Best Friend to Buy

Out of every beef tallow balm we reviewed, Serabel was clearly different. From the very first week of testing, it left the other balms in the dust.

Our testers consistently reported softer, more hydrated skin, reduced redness and breakouts, and visibly smoother texture. As the weeks went on, many began to notice fine lines fading and a natural, healthy glow returning to their skin.

And it all happened without any complicated routine. Just apply morning and night. Multiple testers described this experience as "life-changing."

And most telling of all... most of our testers continued using Serabel after the test period was over. This wasn't true for any other balm on the list. Only Serabel.

Serabel’s formula is carefully balanced, backed by real science, and crafted with the purest ingredients: 100% grass-fed beef tallow, cold-pressed olive oil, natural beeswax, raw honey, and vitamin E.

In short: If you want the balm that checks every box for effectiveness, purity, and results, Serabel is the clear winner.

We Got Them to Offer 50% OFF to Our Readers Right Now (Likely to Sell Out)

Why it's #1:

100% Grass-Fed, Grass-Finished Beef Tallow — This is the gold standard. Grass-fed tallow is packed with vitamins A, D, E, and K — the nutrients your skin craves. Serabel sources from regenerative farms, so you're getting tallow that's pure, nutrient-dense, and free from hormones or antibiotics.

Dry-Rendered for Maximum Potency — Unlike wet-rendered tallow (which loses nutrients during high-heat processing), Serabel uses a slow, dry-rendering method that preserves every vitamin and fatty acid. This means your skin gets the full benefit of the tallow.

Complete Formula with Raw Honey, Olive Oil, Beeswax & Vitamin E — Raw honey provides antibacterial and anti-inflammatory benefits. Olive oil delivers antioxidants and aids absorption. Beeswax creates a protective barrier. Vitamin E protects from free radical damage and helps fade scars and dark spots.

Full Transparency — Every ingredient and dose is clearly listed. Each jar is expertly formulated and manufactured to consistent standards.

PROS

CONS

Our experience: Testers reported softer, more hydrated skin within the first week, reduced breakouts and redness, and noticeably smoother texture. Over several weeks, fine lines softened and skin looked more radiant.

Bottom line: Serabel offers the strongest combination of the right ingredients, in the right balance, with the right sourcing and rendering methods. And the results show it. Serabel is the clear winner, hands down.

We Got Them to Offer 50% OFF to Our Readers Right Now (Likely to Sell Out)

Terra Lotus takes a very traditional approach with a simple mix of grass-fed beef tallow, olive oil, beeswax, and raw honey. It’s a clean, minimal formula

The brand emphasizes its balm texture, formulated for deep moisture and protection. It’s a dense, waxy consistency that some users appreciate for its richness.

Some however describe it as feeling "like Vaseline" — thick, slow to absorb, and sitting on the skin rather than fully blending in. Because of that, it’s often preferred for small dry patches instead of daily all-over use.

While Serabel uses the same base ingredients, its whipped, airy texture melts in instantly and absorbs cleanly, delivering hydration without the heaviness or greasy finish.

PROS

CONS

Verdict: A good choice for those who don’t mind a heavier texture that takes longer to absorb.

Evil Goods has built a loyal following with its bold “no BS” philosophy and focus on quality ingredients — grass-fed beef tallow, Manuka honey, olive oil, calendula flower extract, and vitamin E.

The balm is marketed as whipped and lightweight, but in use, the texture feels heavier than expected. Many users found it thick and greasy, noting that it tends to sit on the skin rather than absorb fully.

Staying true to its “no BS” philosophy, the balm has a natural, unmasked tallow scent that some found stronger than expected.

PROS

CONS

Verdict: A clean, straightforward formula that delivers moisture, but the heavy texture and scent make it less ideal for everyday wear.

Forge markets heavily to men looking to reduce wrinkles and improve skin firmness, but the formula works for anyone targeting anti-aging concerns.

Here's the problem: Forge isn't actually a tallow balm.

While it contains some tallow, the formula is loaded with synthetic chemicals, preservatives, and fillers. The ingredient list includes water, glycerin, multiple synthetic emulsifiers (PEG-100 Stearate, Polysorbate 60), preservatives (Butylene Glycol, Propylene Glycol), synthetic fragrance, and artificial dyes (FD&C Yellow No. 5 and No. 6)

This is the exact opposite of what people want when they're looking for a clean, natural tallow balm.

If you're seeking the benefits of grass-fed tallow and raw honey without synthetic chemicals, Forge completely misses the mark.

PROS

CONS

Verdict: If you want a conventional anti-aging cream that happens to contain some tallow, this could work. But if you're looking for a clean, pure tallow balm, skip this one.

Neptune has built a following around its minimalist approach and clean ingredient list — grass-fed tallow, Manuka honey, olive oil, and beeswax.

The brand emphasizes its natural simplicity, but the texture feels thick and heavy, similar to what some users described with Terra Lotus. It tends to sit on the surface rather than absorb fully, leaving the skin feeling coated instead of deeply hydrated.

It delivers moisture and protection, but lacks the light, fast-absorbing texture that makes higher-ranked balms feel more refined and comfortable for daily use.

PROS

CONS

Verdict: Could work for some, but not competitive on quality or consistency.